Pokémon Yellow Version: Special Pikachu Edition

The Good
There are references to the Pokémon anime such as of course having Pikachu as your starter and not wanting to evolve into a Raichu and having it's cry based on Ikue Otani's voice and Jesse and James from Team Rocket making multiple appearances with their Pokémon from the anime. The front sprites of the Pokémon have been designed to more resemble the official artwork.

Some Pokémon have slightly tweaked movesets and some trainers and gym leaders have different Pokémon, so it won't feel completely the same if you played any of the other two versions and have access to different Pokémon such as the three starters from Red and Blue. This allows you to have the same team Ash Ketchum had during the show.

The Bad
Not much has changed since it's still a generation I game so all the flaws from Red and Blue are still here, including the ugly back sprites which stick out even more with the vastly improved front sprites. If you want a Raichu to complete your Pokédex, you have to trade one from Red, Blue, Gold, Silver, or Crystal along with the other Pokémon that are excluded from the wild in this version.

Pikachu is statically the worst starter in the entire franchise since you can't evolve it so it's a waste of a slot unless you grind it to be a higher level especially at the Elite Four.

The Bottom Line
Play it, don't play it, I don't care. If you want to try a Pokémon game from gen I, any version is fine but if you already played Red, Blue or even both, you decide for yourself. If you did watch the anime back in the 90's, then you'll enjoy the game more.

The Good
This game is the ultimate, it's got everything from the previous Pokemon games, and this game is also based on the TV series, that's right, you'll get to meet Jessy, James, and Meowth! Some of the rare pokemon are free to catch like Scyther, and Dragonair. The game's basic fun is the new features in it, the pokemon, trainers, and even Giovanni look exactly like they look in the TV series. You have to take Pikachu at the beginning, I kept my Pikachu for playing with, imagine I finished the game and he's still at level 27!

The Bad
The color (although way better than before) is still not colorful enough.

The Bottom Line
RPG fans, your favorite genre just took a huge step into a delightful future. Adventure fans, your favorite genre just took a twist (not for the better, but for difference). Puzzle freaks, don't look forward to much. RPG just got better, and so did Pokemon. 5/5. Wonderful.

The Good
Just to clarify, the main difference between Yellow and Red/Blue is that you don't choose to start with one of three Pokemon (Charmander, Bulbasaur, Squirtle) but, just like in the animated series, with Pikachu. Oh, and it has some Color too, if you own a GBC or GBA, which Blue and Red did not.

Well, essentially it's a role-playing game. I'm very sure that it borrows heavily from the early Final Fantasy adventures for the original Game Boy (remember those?), although in a more child-oriented world. Thus, it appeases both the Pokemon-lover (and I do admit it, I am one - Pokemon certainly had more class and style than the later clones like Digimon, Yu-Gi-Oh, etc.) as well as the role-player, which I also have been for many years. Your "party" are actually up to 6 Pokemon that you can raise in levels and customize via items called "training machines", etc., you explore the landscape and battle "boss monsters" (okay, rivaling gym leaders) and "wandering monsters" (rivaling trainers), but same concept really. The game is a lot of fun with the right difficulty level - high enough to be challenging, yet low enough to allow fairly fluid advancement.

Also, the replay value is very high - especially if you own a N64 with Pokemon Stadium. Thus, you can keep leveling your Pokemon and catch and explore more even after beating the game (or while still beating the game, thus keeping it from being linear). If you own an N64, you can import and export your Pokemon - and, more importantly, save your Pokemon, then restart your game and gain experience and items all over again. I simply LOVED the Pokemon Yellow/Pokemon Stadium combo, which basically improved both games tremendously and spawned the current GameCube/e-Reader/GameBoy Advance interaction.

The Bad
Well, if you DON'T have the Pokemon Stadium, the replay value drops from very high to zero. You actually have to delete your Pokemon to restart, and you have to restart in order to gain certain skills/items (a lot only exist once in the game). Also, it's not really a "stand-alone" version of the game - initially, there were Pokemon Blue and Red, and by linking the two, you could eventually get all 150 Pokemon, as some only existed in Blue and some only in Red. Yellow has a new set; however Blue+Yellow doesn't give you all, neither does Red+Yellow, thus to complete a collection of all 150 you STILL had to own Blue+Red, thus making Yellow useless for that purpose.

Also, the fact that you HAVE to start with Pikachu is a little silly... since the storyline deviates zero from Red/Blue, the first "boss" you have to defeat is the Rock/Ground trainer, against whom Pikachu is useless, thus causing one of the harder battles in the game fairly early. That's just being shortsighted, promote a game in which you finally can play with Pikachu (YEE-HAW!!!) but when you actually have to use him to win a big battle, he sucks (DOH!) and he can't evolve either because he never does in the series.

Oh, and you can't transfer Pokemon to the new GameCube/GB Advance Pokemon games, so if you get those, your collection of raised and nurtured Pokemon starts all over again. Would it really have killed Nintendo to allow this?

The Bottom Line
Good game, enjoyed it for many hours and still do. But the game becomes about ten times as good if you also own Pokemon Stadium, as you basically unlock whole modes of play while using both. Make sure you enjoy the Pokemon Universe and the game concept before getting this though, it's certainly not for everyone. Also, I doubt if it's really a good game for really young kids, because it requires a lot of patience.